The Pros And Cons Of Hippocrates - 1771 Words

Socrates demonstrates that Hippocrates ought to engage in philosophical inquiry, especially if he is to have such strong political ambitions. Socrates is engaging with Protagoras on behalf of Hippocrates. Protagoras is also addressing Hippocrates, and his counterparts, in making his claims about what he is able to teach. In this essay, I am concerned with reconstructing Socrates’ reasoning behind his conclusion that Hippocrates should not want to study under Protagoras. I will then offer an objection for Hippocrates, and finally from this, drawing a conclusion as to whether or not Hippocrates should pay to be a pupil of Protagoras. Socrates’ main argument addressed to Hippocrates, before arriving to question Protagoras at the house of†¦show more content†¦Every day, day after day, you will get better and better† (Prot. 318b). Socrates has two objections: the first being that when the people of Athens meet at the Assembly to discuss certain issues, like bu ilding a new ship, or architecture, they will ask an expert in this, but do not enact the opinions of anyone besides these experts. However, in a situation where the discussion is in regard to the politics of the city (i.e., a new law) they will consider the opinions of all citizens, despite not all individuals learned about the subject discussed (Prot. 319b). The second objection raised by Socrates is that he doesn’t believe excellence can be taught because of the numerous examples of good men who have bad kids (Prot. 320a). The main formal argument begins with Protagoras’ great speech. Before his great speech, Protagoras commits himself to the notion that virtue can be taught (Prot. 319a), and Socrates, instead of refuting the point as he normally would, gives Protagoras the chance to further make his argument through a great speech. The great speech is divided into two parts: the myth (320d-324d) and the main argument (324d-328d). He maintains through both parts of the speech that virtue is something that can be taught, and thatShow MoreRelatedMonica Ashley Case Essay1009 Words   |  5 PagesWhy do you think that Monica Ashley was so interested in pushing so hard to implement Project Hippocrates? What made her interested in the project? At first Monica was not interested in leading Project Hippocrates, she intended on moving up in the ranks within her company. However, she was known for intensity and energy when working on a project and figured that she would throw herself at the project and perhaps after one more high-profile success she could move out of program/project managementRead MoreThe Legalization Of Physician Assisted Suicide1720 Words   |  7 PagesHippocratic oath instructs physicians to refuse their patients requests for treatments that cause death. Physicians are not ethically allowed to be involved in ending a terminally ill patient s life solely because of their pledge to â€Å"do no harm†. As Hippocrates puts it: â€Å"Nor shall any man’s entreaty prevail upon me to administer poison to anyone†. However, this would be forcing the terminally ill patients to endure suffering when they would rather be at peace. Now physician-assisted suicide is legal inRead MoreIs Euthanasia A Mercy Killing Or Assisted Suicide?947 Words   |  4 Pagesresort to. (â€Å"10 Arguments For Legalizing Euthanasia†) The Hippocratic Oath is one taken by physicians to treat the ill to the best of one’s ability, to preserve a patient’s privacy, and so on. It has been adjusted through history, since written by Hippocrates. Summating to â€Å"do no harm†, doctors have used the oath as a guide to their actions in practice. (Hippocratic Oath) Some interpret this to mean that doctors shouldn’t do anything that would affect the patient’s chanced of survival. This oath couldRead MoreEssay Pros and Cons of Abortion3507 Words   |  15 PagesPros and Cons of Abortion Should a list of pros and cons of abortion really be necessary for Christians...or human beings for that matter? I mean, have we really reached a point where we cannot tell that abortion is murderous no matter how you color it or try to paint it as compassionate? Apparently so. Thirty plus years after the infamous Supreme Court decision in Roe versus Wade and thirty one years after my own timely birth, I sit in awe at the ignorance of a great portion of society..Read MoreAbortion Is An Action That Ends Pregnancy Before The Unborn1773 Words   |  8 Pagesoutside the mother s body. Debate dates to Assyrian culture in the â€Å"fourteenth century BCE† and in early Hebrew law (Kaplan, Tischauser, Chara, 2014). Historical reasons according to Kaplan, Tischauser, Chara for debate are listed as follows: Hippocrates said â€Å"it violated a doctor s responsibility to heal†, Roman law was based on an unborn being part of the woman which makes it her decision, unwanted pregnancies are reason enough in some cultures, Christian churches see abortion as sin and murderRead MoreHerpes Virus : Herpes Simplex Virus1281 Words   |  6 Pagesvirus and one of the oldest STDs that has been known and been treated. Even though the virus has been around for man y years, it has only been fully understood in the last hundred years. The early discoveries of the herpes virus was discovered, by Hippocrates, a Greek physician who wrote about the symptoms of the herpes lesions. The name Herpes comes from the greek word herpein, which means creep and crawl. How Greeks described how the herpes sores spread. The herpes virus is also known as the herpesRead MoreRisk And Risk Management Department : A Plan For Reducing The Frequency And Severity Of Accidents And Injuries1283 Words   |  6 Pageschronic pain treatment for adults 18 years and older. (Dowell, Haegerich, Chou, 2016) Analyze the Problem Opioid Narcotics Narcotics have been used for recreational and medical uses during ancient Chinese, Greek, Roman, and Egyptian empires. Hippocrates and others aristocrats smoked or chewed poppy leaves to relax. The poppy leafs were chewed to produce analgesic effects as far back as the 1700s and even earlier in some cases. (History of Narcotics, n.d., para. 4) Narcotics are legally usedRead MoreEssay about Cultural History of Alcohol1104 Words   |  5 Pagesages mostly for pleasure, but it can be seen the many instances where it has been a cure for many aliments. In ancients times people would drinking alcohol due to the fact it was cleanlier than early water sources. in ancient Greece, Plato And Hippocrates, would identify numerous medicinal properties of wine and saw it as beneficial to health and happiness. The Hebrews saw wine as a widely appreciated medicine and an essential element in their daily life. The invention of gin was originally usedRead MoreCrisis Management Communication Plan1291 Words   |  6 PagesIneffective or miscommunication in health care setting can lead to unnecessary death and serious Injury. In health care setting organization safety is generally define as freedom from accidental. Because the days of Hippocrates, the concept of ‘do not harm’ has been incorporate into Health care ethical practice. At the time of disaster effective communication very important so That everyone understand, especially team member so that canRead MoreEuthanasi An Incurable Form Of Cancer Essay1488 Words   |  6 Pagesgive a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect,† clearly stands against the use of euthanasia (Tyson). How could health care providers work to heal a person while holding the power to kill the person? Hippocrates knew from the very beginning euthanasia was not moral or ethical and murder in the medical field should not be allowed. The legalizing of euthanasia would deteriorate the patient-care giver trust because the patient would fear the new capacity the